Top 5 NCAA March Madness Upsets That Shocked the Nation

March Madness is much more than a basketball tournament—it’s a phenomenon that keeps sports fans and casual viewers alike on the edge of their seats every spring.

The tournament has a reputation for unpredictability, where underdog teams, lovingly dubbed “Cinderellas,” upset powerhouse programs in moments that defy expectations.

Jersey City 2025 Deals!
Get a discount of 15% to 70% on accommodation in Jersey City! Look for deals here:
Jersey City Hotels, Apartments, B&Bs

Let’s take a closer look at some of the greatest upsets in NCAA Tournament history and the recurring themes that make March Madness so captivating year after year.

The Thrill of the Underdog: Cinderella Stories in March Madness

The NCAA’s inclusion of all 31 conference champions, regardless of their size or national profile, allows smaller programs the chance to compete with basketball juggernauts.

The outcome? A tournament loaded with potential for shocking upsets and unforgettable moments.

Whether it’s a 15-seed defying all odds or a 16-seed conquering what was once thought impossible, March Madness consistently delivers heroics that reinvigorate our love for the underdog.

Historic Firsts: Teams That Changed the Game

In 2018, the University of Maryland, Baltimore County (UMBC) made history by becoming the first 16-seed to defeat a 1-seed, dominating top-ranked Virginia in a surprising 74-54 victory.

Similarly, Fairleigh Dickinson captured headlines in 2023, defying odds as a 16-seed to topple Purdue without even winning their own conference championship.

These victories proved that no team should ever be taken lightly in this thrilling tournament.

Another monumental moment came in 2013 when Florida Gulf Coast University (FGCU), dubbed “Dunk City” for their electrifying playstyle, became the first 15-seed to make it to the Sweet 16.

Their victories over powerhouse programs Georgetown and San Diego State are still celebrated as defining moments in tournament history.

The Rise of Oral Roberts and Saint Peter’s

Recent tournaments have seen the emergence of teams like Oral Roberts and Saint Peter’s University.

In 2021, Oral Roberts pulled off an incredible run as a 15-seed, defeating Ohio State and Florida before a narrow loss to Arkansas in the Sweet 16.

Standout performances from stars Kevin Obanor and Max Abmas combined with excellent coaching propelled them into the national spotlight.

Jersey City Pride: Saint Peter’s University’s Dramatic 2022 Run

No discussion of tournament upsets is complete without mentioning Saint Peter’s University—the pride of Jersey City.

In 2022, the Peacocks cemented their place in history as the first 15-seed to advance to the Elite Eight.

Their improbable victories over Kentucky, Murray State, and Purdue were led by gritty teamwork and stellar coaching from Shaheen Holloway.

Holloway’s deep ties to New Jersey brought even more attention to this historic run; after the tournament, he returned to coach at his alma mater, Seton Hall.

Saint Peter’s magical journey didn’t just thrill basketball fans—it also put Jersey City in the national spotlight.

Visitors now flock to the city to witness where the Cinderella story unfolded, making local businesses and areas surrounding the university buzz with renewed energy.

Looking Back to Move Forward

The beauty of March Madness lies in its unpredictability.

For every UMBC or Fairleigh Dickinson, there’s a Virginia—a team that bounces back stronger after a shocking loss.

Just one year after losing to UMBC, Virginia returned to claim the national championship, a testament to their resilience and grit.

For coaches of underdog teams, tournament success can serve as a launching pad for new opportunities.

FGCU’s Andy Enfield parlayed his success into a job at USC, while Jersey City’s Shaheen Holloway found his next chapter at Seton Hall.

Jersey City: A Hub for Sports Fans and Visitors Alike

The tournament’s drama often extends beyond the court, creating ripple effects for the cities these teams represent.

For Jersey City, home to Saint Peter’s University, the 2022 NCAA Tournament run turned the city into a destination for basketball enthusiasts.

Guests have discovered not just a rich sports history but also a vibrant city full of charm.

For travelers seeking where to stay in Jersey City, a variety of options are available, ranging from boutique accommodations to luxurious Jersey City hotels with riverfront views.

Once in town, there’s no shortage of things to do in Jersey City, from strolling along the waterfront in Liberty State Park to indulging in the city’s diverse culinary scene.

Exploring the distinct personality of its city districts, each with unique restaurants, shops, and attractions, is a must for visitors.

Your Guide to Getting to Jersey City

Curious about getting to Jersey City? Conveniently located just across the Hudson River from Manhattan, it’s accessible by PATH, ferries, or even a quick drive from Newark Liberty Airport.

Whether you’re cheering on your favorite team or diving into the local culture, Jersey City easily welcomes travelers from all walks of life.

March Madness is about more than basketball—it’s about the stories that emerge from unexpected triumph and the connections they create.

In Jersey City, the legacy of Saint Peter’s 2022 run continues to inspire, connecting this vibrant city to the heartbeat of college basketball history.

Jersey City 2025 Deals!
Get a discount of 15% to 70% on accommodation in Jersey City! Look for deals here:
Jersey City Hotels, Apartments, B&Bs

 
Here is the source article for this story: 5 Greatest March Madness Upsets In NCAA Men’s Tournament History

Where to Stay in Jersey City, NJ – Hotels, Vacation Rentals, BnBs

Exploring Jersey City means experiencing a unique blend of vibrant culture, stunning views, and easy access to New York City. This bustling city offers a range of accommodation options to ...

Things to Do in Jersey City, NJ

Jersey City, nestled along the Hudson River's western banks, offers a perfect getaway within arm’s reach of New York. You'll find plenty to do, from waterfront parks providing stunning views ...

Plan Your Stay in Jersey City, NJ

Discover the charm of Jersey City, NJ, where urban flair meets cultural richness. Nestled across the Hudson River, this vibrant city offers stunning views of Manhattan and easy access to ...

Getting Around Jersey City, NJ

Jersey City, NJ, is a vibrant and bustling place, perfect for exploration and adventure. Public transportation in Jersey City offers convenient and diverse commuting options that help improve accessibility and ...
Scroll to Top